Best Baby Baptism Gifts for Girls Ideas featured image - Baby Journey

23 Baby Baptism Gifts for Girls Ideas

Are you invited to a little girl’s baptism and now are wondering what to get her for this occasion? Picking the right baptism gifts for girls can be tricky because you have to find unique, practical, memorable, and most importantly, the little girl should like it!

You can also discuss with the parents if they have ordered a baptism cake. If they haven’t you can get one as a present!

Because I know how hard it is to pick a girl baptism gift, I gathered up 20+ baptism gifts for baby girl you cannot go wrong with!

I also covered the best baptism presents for girl to get from godparents or closest family, so let’s start!

23 Best Baptism Gifts for Girls Ideas


When it comes to christening and baptism gifts for girls, it is not the price that matters. Some people also give gift cards or money, which is also acceptable. But, these gifts lack soul and personal value. Go through the following list before you throw in some cash for the upcoming baby girl’s baptism celebration.

Some great christening gifts for girls include keepsake jewelry pieces, baptismal souvenirs for baby girl, toys, and other cute items. Check the list to find out what to buy for a baptism girl!

Baptism Gifts for Baby Girl

The best christening gifts for baby girl don’t have to be expensive. Instead, aim for practical, unique, and personalized baptism gifts for baby girl that will show how much you thought of a little princess!

#1 Book Of Prayers

Baby's First Book of Prayers (Baby’s First Series)

Every little angel needs a book of prayers! This one by Melody Carlson and Judit Pfeiffer contains 41 beautifully illustrated prayers. It comes in hardcover and is an excellent idea for bedtime reading!

Baby's First Book of Prayers (Baby’s First Series)
  • Hardcover Book
  • Carlson, Melody (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)

#2 Porcelain Figure

Precious Moments, You Are A Child Of God, Bisque Porcelain Cross, Girl, 4004681

When choosing gifts for baby girl baptism related, think about simple baptism girl gifts. A beautiful porcelain figure with a cross and baptism information about the date, time, and place is an adorable gift.

Parents can display it in the nursery, and the baby can keep it as a beautiful reminder on her baptism day.

Precious Moments, You Are A Child Of God, Bisque Porcelain Cross, Girl, 4004681
  • Bright-eyed and full of wonder, this precious baby girl has just been baptized into God's family. Commemorative cross features space on the back for you to write Baby's name and christening date (pen not included).
  • A constant reminder that Baby Girl is loved and protected for all of her days; it is a faith-filled addition to her nursery
  • Give this intricate cross as a lasting reminder of her baptismal day and it is sure to be treasured throughout her childhood and beyond

#3 Plush Toy with Message

Plush Toy with Message - Baby Baptism Gifts for Girls Ideas - Baby Journey
Source: IndiePrintsCo

Every little girl needs a plush toy! So, these soft and warm toys can be used as christening presents for girls. To make a toy even better, you can add a message. Include personalized baptism congratulatory messages or general information on baptism.

Add beautiful packaging, and the teddy can quickly become one of the best gift ideas for baptism girl.

#4 Pacifier Holder

Baby pacifier holder - Baby Baptism Gifts for Girls Ideas - Baby Journey
Source: IePeda

Is the baby always holding her paci? Great, here is your idea! Get her a personalized wooden pacifier holder with a cross and her name. It is a beautiful and long-lasting gift for a baby girl.

#5 Ultimate Honey Bug Gift box

Moon & Stars Gift Box by HoneyBug - Baby Baptism Gifts for Girls Ideas - Baby Journey
Source: HoneyBug

Distant relatives might struggle to pick the appropriate Catholic baptism gifts for baby girls. That is when gift boxes come into the spotlight!

Honey Bug makes excellent gift boxes that contain everything a baby girl might need in the first couple of months.

Girl Baptism Gifts from Godparents

Baptism gifts for goddaughter take a special place on my list. Check out my ideas and suggest more of them in the comments!

#6 Christening Candle Set

Christening Candle Set - Baby Baptism Presents for Girls Ideas - Baby Journey
Source: Burbvus

You can have your girl baptized without all the fancy baptism decorations, but a candle set is a must.

Pick an elegant, handmade candle set to show how honored you are to be some godparent!

#7 Personalized Rattle

Silver personalized rattle - Girl baptism gift from godmother - Baby Journey
Source: myCloverShop

Silver, personalized rattle is a more expensive baptism gift from godmother but it is worth it.

The rattle is long-lasting, and valuable and arrives in beautiful packaging. You can pick a smaller size rattle that can fit into little girl baby hands!

#8 Christening Blanket

Christening blanket - Girl Baptism Gifts from Godparents Ideas - Baby Journey
Source: AngelskyTM

Another lovely christening gift from godfather to girl is a christening blanket. It is designed to absorb moisture. If the baptism is during cold weather, the manufacturers allow you to order one with insulation.

Overall, a soft and pretty blanket with beautiful details is an alternative if you don’t want to buy baptism jewelry for baby girl, and you want something more practical.

Christening and Baptism Gifts for Girl from Grandparents

Proud grandparents often struggle to choose a baptism gift for granddaughter that the baby will love and parents will appreciate.

Baptism is an event to remember that can cost a lot, especially if parents decide to have a crowdy reception. Check out some practical baby girl christening gifts you probably haven’t thought of!

#9 Carry Cot

Finn+Emma Carry Cot - Christening gift ideas for girl - Baby Journey
Source: Finn+Emma

If parents are baptizing a newborn, they might not still have functional baby equipment, like a carrycot. The one from Finn + Emma is a modern version of a classic Moses basket made from premium materials. It fits wonderfully in the baptism theme!

#10 Play Gym

Lovevery Play gym - Christening gift ideas for girl - Baby Journey
Source: Lovevery

A play gym isn’t one of the common christening gift ideas for girl. However, every baby girl must work on visual tracking and motor skills.

Pick one with several developmental zones and durable materials, like the one from Lovevery. The baby girl’s parents will surely appreciate such a thoughtful gift!

When the baby outgrows it, parents can use it as a play mat for toddlers.

#11 Swing

Finn+Emma Macrame Swing - Baptism Gifts for Girls Ideas - Baby Journey
Source: Finn+Emma

If you live in a different city and cannot visit her often to take the baby to the playground, get her a convenient macrame swing. It is suitable for indoor and outdoor use, and every time the baby is swinging, the little princess will feel loved and think of you!

#12 Balance Board

Finn+Emma Balance Board - Grandparents' gift for baptism girl - Baby Journey
Source: Finn+Emma

Lastly, consider a balance board as a grandparents’ gift for baptism. Quality, well-made balance boards are pricy, but their benefits are vast. Pick one which can turn into a Montessori toy for toddlers and has an elegant design.

Also read: Montessori Toy for Toddlers

Unique Baptism Gifts for Girl

Here are several more gift ideas for baby girl baptism, which stand out with personalization and originality.

Stop wondering what to get a baby girl for baptism and dive into my list. I am sure you will find something appropriate and unique that fits your budget.

#13 Personalized Baptism Cross

Baptism cross classical baptism gift for girls - Baby Journey
Source: alovelydetail

A baptism cross for girl is a classical baptism gift. But what makes it unique are the personalized details. The cross can have the baby girl’s name carved in the wood alongside a couple more details.

#14 Trinket Box

Trinket box baptism keepsake box - Gift ideas for baby girl baptism - Baby Journey
Source: SpokenGifts

A trinket box is a lovely gift for a special occasion like a baptism. The girl can use the box to keep all the jewelry and miniature presents she gets for baptism. If you engrave the message, the box becomes a keepsake present!

#15 Personalized Musical Carousel

Personalized Musical Carousel with baby’s name - Gift ideas for baby girl baptism - Baby Journey
Source: TreatsnWonders

A musical carousel with a baby’s name will quickly become a little kid’s favorite nursery decoration. It will look good in any baby girl’s room and can keep babies amused for some time.

#16 Ponycycle

Ponycycle - Unique baptism girl present - Baby Journey
Source: PishPoshBaby

Do you want to pick the best baptism girl present ever? Get a ponycycle and the little princess will feel so special!

It is an expensive baptism gift worth gifting that works on human motion simulation and allows little girls more freedom in movement.

Baptism Girl Gifts for Twins

Twins are a special blessing from God, but having them complicates things with choosing a present, complicates things! Whether you are a parent, guest, godparent, or relative, here are several baptism gift ideas for twin girls!

#17 Matching Necklaces

Matching Necklaces for twin girls - Baptism Girl Gifts for Twins - Baby Journey
Source: SwedishBeautyDesign

Twin girls have a special bond, which gets stronger with the years! Getting them a set of matching necklaces is a lovely, keepsake gift they will save for years and wear proudly!

#18 Swaddle set

Spotted Play 2 Pack Sherpa Baby Swaddle Blanket - Ultra Soft Plush for Infants 0-6 Months | Receiving Swaddling Wrap - Ideal Newborn Registry and Toddler Boy Accessories | Nursery Blankets - White

Parents of twin girls can easily get overwhelmed, so swaddling can help babies sleep better so parents can rest, too. Getting a comfortable swaddle set for twins is a practical and thoughtful present.

It is also suitable for getting babies outside during cold weather!

Spotted Play 2 Pack Sherpa Baby Swaddle Blanket - Ultra Soft Plush for Infants 0-6 Months | Receiving Swaddling Wrap - Ideal Newborn Registry and Toddler Boy Accessories | Nursery Blankets - White
  • 【LUXURIOUS SOFTNESS】 - High quality material, super warm and soft blanket, not heavy for babies tender skin
  • 【Suitable for baby from 0-6 Month】Features: Adjustable baby's hook and loop, free to adjust swaddle size.With separate feet,it allowing baby to kick,but cannot be kicked off.Cute bear hoodie, protecting baby's ear,stay warm all night.
  • 【Extra Soft Blanket】 - Hooded Baby Blanket Swaddle Wrap Blanket 24*11*1.2 inches extra thick. Easy to wash, perfect Baby Shower Gift for babies and infant whit sensitive skin and skin conditions.

#19 Personalized Comforters Set

Personalized Comforters Set for Twin Girls - Baptism Girl Gifts for Twins - Baby Journey
Source: thebababee

A set of plush comforters with twin girls’ names on them is a heart-warming baptism present that won’t break the bank, but will show how much you love girls! You can customize the comforters’ shape, color, and name!

Beautiful Baptism Gifts for Older Girl

If you’ve been invited to a baptism of an older girl, skip the toys and clothes, and pick something else. Here are a couple of unique baptism gifts for girl of school age or older.

Christening gifts she can keep or read over and over are great ways to welcome a new member to your church. The following gifts for girls are also suitable for all religious milestones she’ll celebrate throughout life!

#20 Bracelet

Bracelet jewelry baptism gift for older girl - Baby Journey
Source: BJHLondon

A sparkling piece of jewelry is always a good idea if you are searching for baptism gifts for teenage girl. A handmade silver bracelet made in a minimalistic style with subtle details will match every fashion style the girl might be into now.

#21 Angel Wing Protection Necklace

Ioka 14K Yellow Gold Dainty Angel Pendant Religious Charm with 0.5mm Box Chain Necklace For Women - 16'

An angel wing protection necklace is one of most people’s favorite Catholic baptism gifts for girl. It is also a beautiful present from godparents, symbolizing guardian angels!

Ioka 14K Yellow Gold Dainty Angel Pendant Religious Charm with 0.5mm Box Chain Necklace For Women - 16"
  • 14K Real Gold Necklace Chain with Pendant that will last Long and is Tarnish Free.
  • Pendant Height: 0.47 inches (12 MM) Width: 0.39 inches (10 MM) Average Weight: 0.81 grams
  • Chain Width: 0.5 MM Clasp Type: Spring Ring Fits Into Bale : 8; Made in America with High Quality Metals Strong and Secure to hold Pendant charms.

#22 Girl Bible

NIV, Ultimate Bible for Girls, Faithgirlz Edition, Hardcover

Incorporating religion into challenging teenage years is a tough job! But, with the help of this Girl Bible, things might get easier.

Teenage girls are too young to read The Bible and understand it, but they are ready for some interesting bible-related material.

This Girl Bible is the perfect way to help young girls understand the story of God.

NIV, Ultimate Bible for Girls, Faithgirlz Edition, Hardcover
  • Hardcover Book
  • Rue, Nancy N. (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)

#23 Doodle Devotions Book

Doodle Devotions for Girls

If you want engaging baptism presents that a girl will never get enough of, try a Doodle Devotions Book by Nancy Taylor. It helps girls learn about important things, family, love, abundance, secrets, choices, and more.

Doodle Devotions for Girls
  • Nancy Taylor (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 152 Pages - 12/07/2018 (Publication Date) - Christian Art Publishers (Publisher)


Have you picked christening gifts for baby girl? I prefer the carrycot and personalized musical carousel! What about you?

Is it easier to pick cool baptism gifts for boy or girl? Why? I think girls are a simpler category for baby baptism gifts.

Cute toys and personalized items in white or pink always come to my mind when I think about baby girl baptism gifts.

I hope you found the list useful! Come back for more practical recommendations and articles to help you survive exciting and challenging parts of baby life!

Best Baby Baptism Gifts for Girls Ideas pinterest - Baby Journey

Last update on 2024-02-29 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *